8 / 10
The Blob exists in two memorable versions. Irvin Yeaworth directed the 1958 original. Chuck Russell directed the 1988 remake. Both films involve a gelatinous extraterrestrial that lands in a small American town, dissolves victims into its mass, and grows progressively larger. The 1958 version stars a twenty-eight-year-old Steve McQueen in his first leading role. The 1988 version stars Kevin Dillon and Shawnee Smith. Both films are well-regarded within the creature feature subgenre. The remake is more graphic. The original is more iconic. Both are worth watching.
The 1958 film made approximately four million dollars on a one hundred and ten thousand dollar budget and is one of the most profitable independent films of its decade. The 1988 remake made approximately eight million dollars on a nineteen million dollar budget and was a commercial disappointment despite generally positive reviews. The remake’s failure ended Chuck Russell’s planned creature feature trilogy and contributed to the late-1980s decline of the practical-effects horror cycle.
The 1958 Original
The original works because it commits to its small-town setting. Phoenixville, Pennsylvania is the setting. The diner, the movie theater, the high school, the police station are all recognizable as places in a town that exists. The film treats the town as real. The teenagers are not generic teenagers but specific Phoenixville teenagers. The adults are not generic authority figures but specific small-town authority figures. The setting grounds the alien creature in a way that more abstract settings would not.
Steve McQueen’s performance is the second reason the film works. McQueen was twenty-eight playing a teenager and the age difference is visible. The compensation is McQueen’s specific intensity, which made him plausible as the only adult in a town full of teenagers despite being too old for the role. The film argues that the teenagers were right and the adults were wrong, which became one of the foundational plots of subsequent monster movies. The Blob established a template that John Carpenter and others would adapt across the next several decades.
For Writers
A creature feature that grounds the alien in a specific real-world setting is more effective than one that treats the setting as backdrop. The Blob’s Phoenixville is real geography. The audience can follow it. The lesson is that supernatural or science fiction elements gain credibility from realistic surroundings. The more specific the everyday world, the more disruptive the unusual element feels when it arrives. Generic settings minimize the disruption.
The 1988 Remake
Chuck Russell’s remake is more graphic and more politically conscious than the original. The blob in the remake is the result of secret government experimentation rather than extraterrestrial origin. The third act involves military containment and conspiracy. The practical effects are significantly more elaborate than the original could afford, with characters being partially dissolved in extended graphic sequences that the 1958 film could not have shown.
The remake’s most-praised sequences are the kills. Each death is staged as a specific set piece with specific consequences. The pay phone death. The kitchen sink death. The movie theater death. The film does not soften any of them. The audience watches characters die in real time. The R rating allowed Russell to commit to the body horror that the original could only suggest.
For Writers
A remake that updates a property’s content to match contemporary standards can succeed if the update serves the underlying premise. The 1988 Blob’s graphic kills serve the creature’s threat in ways the 1958 film could not. The lesson is that remakes should ask what the original could not do that the new version can. If the answer is “more graphic violence,” that is a valid creative direction. If the answer is “nothing,” the remake probably should not exist.
The Practical Effects
Both films are practical-effects achievements. The 1958 version used silicone-based jelly mixed with vegetable dye for the blob itself. The substance moved naturally and could absorb objects placed in its path. The 1988 version used multiple techniques including miniatures, full-scale puppet rigs, and air bladders for the dissolution effects. Lyle Conway designed the creature effects for the remake.
Neither version uses computer-generated effects in significant ways. The 1958 film could not have. The 1988 film could have but chose not to, partly for budget reasons and partly because the practical work was producing better results. The remake stands as one of the high-water marks of late-1980s practical horror effects, alongside John Carpenter’s The Thing (1982) and The Fly (1986).
For Writers
Practical effects from the 1980s often look better than CGI from the 2010s because the practical work was photographed rather than rendered. The audience can tell the difference even when they cannot articulate it. The lesson is that effects techniques have aging curves. Practical work ages gradually as standards shift. CGI ages quickly because each generation invalidates the previous. If your work depends on visual effects, consider which technique will look acceptable in twenty years rather than which looks best now.
Craft Note
The 1958 practical Blob effects are the film’s central craft. The silicone gel sculpting and the projection-screen incorporation produced an effect that suggested gradual absorption rather than overt menace. The technique demonstrates that low-budget horror works through suggestion: the audience supplies the threat their imagination is willing to imagine, which is usually more frightening than what the budget could have shown.
The Verdict
8/10 average. 8/10 for the 1958 original. 8/10 for the 1988 remake. Both films are excellent in their specific registers. The original is the more iconic. The remake is the more graphic. Watch the original for the cultural foundation. Watch the remake for the practical effects work. Both reward attention.
FAQ
Is Steve McQueen really in the original?
Yes. The Blob (1958) is his first leading role. He had been working in television and small film roles before. The Blob made him a recognizable presence.
How violent is the remake?
Significantly more graphic than the original. R-rated. Includes substantial body horror.
Did Burt Bacharach write the theme song?
Yes. “The Blob” was co-written by Bacharach and Mack David. The song is one of the most-recognized opening themes in 1950s science fiction.
Who is Chuck Russell?
American director. A Nightmare on Elm Street 3: Dream Warriors (1987), The Blob (1988), The Mask (1994), Eraser (1996). Specializes in genre cinema.
Who is Frank Darabont?
American writer-director who co-wrote the 1988 remake before going on to direct The Shawshank Redemption (1994) and The Green Mile (1999). The Blob was an early credit.
Is there a third version?
Beware! The Blob (1972) is a low-budget sequel to the original. A third remake has been in development for years without production. The 2022 Stranger Things-adjacent revival concept never materialized.
Should I watch this?
Yes. Both versions. The originals first.